Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square North Reviews & Red Flags Check: Is It Worth Booking?
Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square North
Probably OK
New York, NY, USA
https://www.expedia.com/New-York-Hotels-Hilton-Garden-Inn-New-York-Times-Square-North.h11718114.Hotel-Information
What To Expect
Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square North is an upscale hotel located conveniently near major attractions like Rockefeller Center and Times Square. Guests often appreciate the comfortable beds and the cleanliness of the rooms, which tends to be a highlight of their stay. However, some guests have reported issues with noise, particularly from the corridors and nearby activities, which may affect sleep quality.
While the staff is frequently praised for their helpfulness, there are recurring complaints about check-in delays and reservation mix-ups that could lead to frustration upon arrival. Additionally, some rooms have been noted to have unpleasant odors, which could detract from the overall experience. The amenities offered, such as a gym and on-site dining, generally meet expectations, but guests should be aware of potential noise and cleanliness concerns that could impact their stay.
Overall, this property seems to offer a solid experience for visitors, but managing expectations around noise and check-in processes will be important for a smoother stay.
Recent Changes
The overall trend appears to be mixed, with some aspects improving while others have declined. Compared with earlier reviews, later feedback indicates that while the cleanliness remains a strong point, noise complaints have become more frequent. Additionally, issues with check-in processes have been highlighted more recently, suggesting a decline in service reliability. Overall, guests should be prepared for potential inconsistencies in their experience.
Deep Inspection Analysis
This place passed 94 out of 100 inspection checks.
Review Pattern & Authenticity
Issues found
1.1 Positive-Framed Complaints:
It appears that guests often express satisfaction with the hotel but also mention significant issues. e.g. Complaints about noise disturbances, check-in delays, and unpleasant odors recur among reviews.
1.10 Rating vs Review Content Mismatch:
It seems that while the overall rating is high, there are recurring complaints about noise and cleanliness. e.g. Guests have noted issues with room odors and disturbances that contrast with the positive rating.
Cleanliness & Hygiene
Issues found
2.3 Odor / Musty Smell:
Some guests have reported musty smells in their rooms, which may affect comfort. e.g. Complaints about mildew and unpleasant odors have been noted in several reviews.
Maintenance & Functionality
Issues found
3.2 HVAC Reliability:
It appears that HVAC systems may not function reliably for all guests, impacting comfort. e.g. Reports of air conditioning units smelling bad and issues with temperature control have been mentioned.
Comfort & Sleep
Issues found
4.5 Noise Reality (Sleep vs Marketing):
It seems that noise levels can disrupt sleep, which may not align with guest expectations for a quiet stay. e.g. Guests have noted disturbances from corridors and nearby activities during their visits.
Check-in & Access
Issues found
5.2 Late Access / Waiting:
It appears that guests may experience long waits during check-in, which can lead to frustration. e.g. Reports of reservation issues and delays have been highlighted in multiple reviews.
Staff/Service Reliability & Policies
All clear
Accuracy & Expectation Fit
All clear
Safety & Surroundings
All clear
Value & Fees
All clear
Trends & Consistency
All clear
Still comparing hotels or vacation rentals?
Run a free AI stay check before you book. BookYolo scans for hidden red flags, review patterns, fee surprises, fake review signals, and expectation gaps.
Check Another Hotel or Vacation Rental15M+ properties covered · No credit card required
More scans
-
Ca'Magica: New and luxury, spectacular canal viewExcellent StayVenice, Veneto, ItalyThis place passed 98 out of 100 inspection checks.Airbnb View scan →
-
Suite House new apartments wi fi Venice islandLooks LegitVenice, Veneto, ItalyThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
The Hive – Holiday Home in TrastevereOutstanding StayRome, ItalyThis place passed 99 out of 100 inspection checks.Agoda View scan →
-
White Swallow Suite SantoriniExcellent StayVourvoulos, Santorini, GreeceThis place passed 98 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Premiere Classe SaintesLooks RiskySaintes, FranceThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
HotelF1 Paris Saint Ouen Marché Aux PucesLooks RiskyParis, Ile de France, FranceThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
hotelF1 Paris VillemombleTravel TrapVillemomble, Ile de France, FranceThis place passed 98 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Hilton London Kensington HotelLooks RiskyKensington and Chelsea, Greater London, UKThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Paco Hotel Tiyuxilu Metro Guangzhou-Free Shuttle Bus during Canton Fair&5 Min walk to Canton Fair Buyer Registration StoreProbably OKGuangzhou, Guangdong, ChinaThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Hotel Le Relais du MaraisProbably OKParis, Paris, FRAThis place passed 98 out of 100 inspection checks.Hotels.com View scan →
-
hotelF1 Paris Saint Ouen – Marché aux PucesLooks RiskyParis, FranceThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Agoda View scan →
-
Hotel Saint Georges LafayetteA Bit RiskyParis, Paris, FRAThis place passed 97 out of 100 inspection checks.Expedia View scan →
-
Apartament l'Areny 21 – 6p – Canillo – Zona GrandvaliraExcellent StayCanillo, AndorraThis place passed 97 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Boho Studio w. Kitchen| Petrol Station & KFCLooks LegitThis place passed 99 out of 100 inspection checks.Airbnb View scan →
-
Mountain View Hotel & ApartmentA Bit RiskyKigali, RwandaThis place passed 94 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
The Ivory SuitesA Bit RiskyMombasa, KenyaThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Omni Orlando Resort at ChampionsgateLooks LegitKissimmee, Florida, USThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Hôtel Des Grands HommesExcellent StayParis, Paris, FRAThis place passed 99 out of 100 inspection checks.Expedia View scan →
-
Embassy Suites By Hilton Orlando Sunset WalkExcellent StayKissimmee, Florida, USThis place passed 97 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Kompose Boutique Resort @ Theme ParksExcellent StayKissimmee, Florida, USThis place passed 97 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Mara Serena Safari LodgeLooks LegitMaasai Mara, KENThis place passed 95 out of 100 inspection checks.Expedia View scan →
-
Avalon HotelLooks LegitMiami Beach, Florida, USThis place passed 98 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
bai Hotel CebuLooks LegitMandaue, Visayas, PhilippinesThis place passed 96 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
-
Cara HotelLooks RiskyHollywood, California, USThis place passed 95 out of 100 inspection checks.Booking.com View scan →
